What oil costs in Stillwater today

This is the live rate from the same system that takes the order, so the number here and the number at checkout cannot disagree.

Standard delivery to Stillwater is ASAP 1-3 Days at no extra charge.

Ariba Oil Co / Price quote No. 0001

Enter your ZIP and we will show you today's actual per-gallon price for your town before you commit to anything. Order online and that price is held for today and tomorrow.

Rather talk to someone? Call 973-375-0770 and tell us the most you want to spend.

Our record here

We already come to Stillwater

160

deliveries since 2019

30,378

gallons dropped here

59

households served

38 mi

from our Irvington yard

Counted from online orders placed since October 2019, when we put ordering on the web. Ariba has been delivering in Sussex County a great deal longer than that.

How Stillwater heats

This is oil country

Oil is how Stillwater heats. 4,469 of the 10,389 households here burn it, 43% of the town. That is not a few holdouts, that is most of the town, and it is mostly because the gas main never came up these roads and is not going to. The tank is the heating system. Running out is not an inconvenience, it is a cold house by morning.

Basement tanks, mostly

The median home in Stillwater was built around 1968, which usually means a 275 gallon tank standing in the basement and a fill pipe on the side of the house. Straightforward to deliver to. It also means a lot of these houses are on their second or third boiler, so if yours is getting temperamental we do burner service as well as fuel.

Heating fuel in Stillwater

Of 10,389 occupied homes.

Heating oil 4,469 / 43%

Natural gas 2,693 / 26%

Electric 1,590 / 15%

Propane 1,032 / 9.9%

Wood 379 / 3.6%

US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2023 5-year estimates, table B25040, for ZIP 07860.

Getting a truck to Stillwater

How fast, and what faster costs

These are the delivery options and prices for Stillwater specifically. They are not the same in every town we serve.

ASAP 1-3 Days No charge

Same Day Weekday $95

Saturday Delivery $145

Sunday Delivery $345

Per delivery, on top of the fuel. The fastest way to get a same-day drop without paying for one is to pay when you order, because a prepaid stop can fill a slot that opens up mid-route and a COD stop cannot.

Coverage

Where in Stillwater we deliver

ZIP codes

07860. All of them are live in the order system, so the price checker above will quote any of them.

Also known as

Mail to this area is addressed to Newton. Same trucks, same prices.

Shared ZIPs

These ZIPs cross into Andover township, Frankford township, Fredon township, Frelinghuysen township, Green township and Hampton township, which we also serve.

Minimum order

Online ordering starts at 100 gallons. Smaller drops in Stillwater are arranged by phone, so call 973-375-0770 if you need less than that.